Week 4 of the 2025 NFL season transformed benchwarmers into fantasy gods overnight, proving that in football, anything can happen when desperation meets opportunity. 🤯 Owners who stubbornly kept faith in underperforming stars finally breathed sighs of relief louder than a Lambeau Field roar as unexpected heroes emerged from the shadows. From a rookie quarterback schooling an undefeated team to a backup running back suddenly looking like prime Derrick Henry, this week’s fantasy landscape felt like finding a winning lottery ticket in last season’s dirty laundry.

week-4-fantasy-football-heroes-unlikely-stars-who-saved-your-roster-image-0

Who predicted Giants rookie QB Jaxson Dart would outduel the Chargers' powerhouse defense? 😲 Not Vegas oddsmakers or fantasy "experts" who buried him after Week 3’s dismal 0.3 points. Yet there he was, channeling peak Lamar Jackson vibes while putting up 19.8 fantasy points against one of the league’s scariest defenses. People Also Ask: Is this a fluke or the start of New York's QB future?

Meanwhile in Kansas City, Xavier Worthy’s return from injury proved more electrifying than Patrick Mahomes’ pregame warmup routine. The wideout didn’t just catch passes—he turned into an offensive Swiss Army knife with 83 receiving yards PLUS 38 rushing yards. His 17.1-point explosion coincided with Mahomes’ season-best performance, making Chiefs fans wonder why they ever stressed about that 1-2 start.

week-4-fantasy-football-heroes-unlikely-stars-who-saved-your-roster-image-1

Darren Waller’s comeback tour in Miami featured more drama than a reality TV finale. After over a year away, the tight end waltzed into the end zone twice against the Bengals like he’d never left. His 17.7-point statement game made fantasy managers wonder if 33 is the new 28 for TEs. 🍾

Then came the Dallas-Green Bay barnburner where George Pickens decided 40-40 ties require personal stat-padding. Eleven catches. 134 yards. Two touchdowns. 33.4 fantasy points that left Packers defenders questioning life choices. People Also Ask: Can he keep this up when defenses scheme specifically for him?

Player Position Fantasy Points Previous High
Kenneth Gainwell RB 31.4 11.2
Ashton Jeanty RB ~35* 10.4
Romeo Doubs WR 29.8 14.1
*estimated based on 3 TDs + yardage

week-4-fantasy-football-heroes-unlikely-stars-who-saved-your-roster-image-2

Speaking of surprises, Las Vegas’ rookie RB Ashton Jeanty finally silenced critics with a 150+ yard, 3-TD masterpiece against Chicago. His early struggles? Blamed entirely on the Raiders' O-line that suddenly blocked like they’d been possessed by 1990s Cowboys legends. 🏈

Not to be outdone, Justice Hill decided Derrick Henry’s backup role needed more spotlight. The Ravens RB exploded for 117 yards and two scores against Kansas City, turning 28.7 fantasy points from a pipe dream into reality. Could this mean a messy timeshare in Baltimore?

In Pittsburgh, Kenneth Gainwell’s 134-yard, 2-TD breakout (31.4 points!!) proved Jaylen Warren’s absence might be the best thing for Steelers fans. Meanwhile, Houston’s Woody Marks made Nick Chubb watchers do double-takes with his 119-total-yard, 2-TD showcase against Tennessee. The fourth-round pick’s 27.9-point eruption begs the question: Is this a one-week wonder or Texas-sized trouble for veteran RBs?

week-4-fantasy-football-heroes-unlikely-stars-who-saved-your-roster-image-3

Even Denver got in on the action when Marvin Mims Jr. reminded everyone he exists with a sneaky 20.5-point game featuring a rushing TD. His performance was so unexpectedly delightful, it left fantasy owners wondering if Bo Nix has secret weapon chemistry with him. 🔥

The real lesson? Week 4 taught us that fantasy relevance can emerge from:

  • Injury chaos (Gainwell/Worthy)

  • Rookie jitters fading (Dart/Jeanty)

  • Veterans finding new life (Waller/Hill)

  • And pure, unadulterated opportunity (Marks/Doubs)

So while we celebrate these unlikely heroes, the looming question remains: Will they become season-long staples or fade back into fantasy obscurity after their 15 minutes of fame? Only the football gods know... and they’re notoriously bad at tweeting spoilers. 🏈✨